The kids & booze debate

03.03.2010
SABMiller campaigns (from the safety of the fence)...
read more

Menu for success

19.02.2010
Beer meets food, happiness ensues...
read more

Chin up, at least you're not in Russia

12.02.2010
Milking the cash cow dry...
read more

The Hop Bine

Newsletter
Email:
Poll: Tasting gender differences
Are men or women better at beer tasting?
Home | The Hop Bine | Button it, beer snobs

Button it, beer snobs

Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font

Bulk beer and sneers

An industry event hosted by a rising star of British craft beer: the usual faces are there, drinking and talking beer. The guest speaker pipes up; lauds the brewer’s doubtless dedication and then, as an aside, bemoans a certain global lager brand’s seeming unfamiliarity with malted barley. Laughter erupts. Bellies wobble. Tipped tankards unmask smug smiles. The bellies wobble on, and on.

 

It was a cheap gag, given the audience. Said lager, one of the country’s biggest sellers, is the devil’s own brew to the beer snob. They cite the use of an adjunct in its grist (though of course not the presence of malted barley), its rock-bottom retail price, its ubiquity and the brand-owner’s at-times ruthless pursuit of profit amongst the litany of gripes they have with the brew.

 

This beer - let’s face it, any corporate bulk-brewed lager - will always get the bile of the beer snob rising. Bottles of it have been symbolically smashed on film in the name of, apparently in all earnestness, the ‘struggle against the faceless bourgeoisie oppression of corporate, soulless beer’. It’s been tipped as a great addition to your compost heap. Some have questioned the difference between the beer before and after its been drunk. It’s the beer beer snobs love to hate.

 

But few beers - so long as the date on its neck is still off in the future and it’s brewed to specification - are worthy of such bedevilment. The fierce resistance of some to the use of adjuncts shows either neglect or ignorance of beer’s evolution over past millennia. Beer will continue to evolve. Change, as the good old weeping philosopher once proclaimed, is the only constant.

 

That popular lager can be bland is not up for debate. In showing the sapid complexities of the interplay between grain, hops, yeast and water, it fails miserably. But that’s not what this drink’s about. It’s about sating growing global demand for beer to celebrate and commiserate, relax and ruminate with, using an ever diminishing pool of resources.

 

Beer, the really good beers like those produced by brewers such as the rising star we visited earlier, should stand tall on their own. The majesty of a good beer and the dedication of a brewer should be able to muster suitable ovation from a commentator without requiring snide references to what is deemed to be a lesser product.

 

Beer snobs do nothing for beer. They alienate people by sneering at the products that most people know as 'beer'. They waste words in the vain hope of fomenting distaste for what they find unpalatable, when they should be sharing with the world what it is that makes beer great. There’s no such thing as a bad beer, it’s just that some are better than others. Let’s talk about those.

Subscribe to comments feed Comments (5 posted):

Kristy on 08 February, 2010 08:45:29
avatar
Couldn't agree more! Suggesting that a beer is bad just because of its size or brewer only serves to perpetuate the myth that beer is the sole preserve of bearded, sandal wearers and will only drive more drinkers into the wine category.

Beer is one of life's simple pleasures whatever your favourite style and as an industry we should be doing more to encourage people to try beer, all beers!!
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
2
MikeMcG on 08 February, 2010 09:05:53
avatar
I totally agree that beer snobs are guilty of turning people off from good beer - snobs of any nature are not pleasant company.

That said, imagine a world in which wine makers, drinkers & commentators only praised both the best of Bordeaux & the New World's finest and the worst of the volume end of the industry.

I can't see a Gilly Goolden-type wine critic saying "Oh this Blue Nun may not do it for me, but some of you out there with shallow pockets & poor tastebuds may go mad for it . . ."

I think it's simplistic to say that there are only 2 ways to appreciate beer - to be totally accepting of all beers regardless of quality, or to be a beer snob.

The sensible & proactive choice to me is to be an advocate for good beer. I'm not so daft to think that large breweries per se cannot make good beer. Often their QC, consistency, etc leave smaller brewers far behind, but they also seem rarely to make distinctive genuinely interesting beers, while in the US & Belgium (& to a lesser extent Germany) it seems for some breweries, size is no barrier to making some truly fantastic beers.

I probably agree that ideally smaller craft-brewers should stick to explaining why their beers are excellent, rather than bashing bigger brewers' beers, but against a world of massive marketing budgets (where everyone's beers use "the finest malts & hops"!) I guess the critical shock-tactics of some micros seems to make sense.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
2
Andrew on 09 February, 2010 12:34:19
avatar
An added problem is too many Brits snicker at lager from their narrow viewpoints. The style has far more nuances than they give it credit for. Historically and technologically it is just as rich as other beers.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
4
MikeMcG on 09 February, 2010 09:42:34
avatar
Agreed there is much more to lager than the pale & fizzy stuff many beer-geeks make disparaging comments about, but perhaps the reason they are so quick to judge is because the vast majority of the lager that's sold in the UK is of this style?
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
0
Matt Hendry on 12 February, 2010 04:04:14
avatar
Cabdice Alstrom has a great Feature about beer snobery in Beer Advocate .Candice republished it on her blog .

http://www.scandalouscandice.com/pork_chops_chicken/2010/01/how-to-lose-friends-and-alienate-the-industry.html?cid=6a00e551becc98883401287772a191970c
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
0
total: 5 | displaying: 1 - 5

Post your comment comment

Please enter the code you see in the image:

  • email Email to a friend
  • print Print version
  • Plain text Plain text
Rate this article
4.75